![[Valid RSS]](/valid-rss.png "Validate my RSS feed")
Here comes Spring Book Release Season! And I have a stack of awesome books to review for you. (Not these, by the way.)
But I want to ask you some things first.
Book reviews have grown more frequent on this blog in the past year, and I’m noticing that more publishers are cultivating blogger reviews. Let’s face it, as magazines stop publication, publishers begin losing outlets to promote new titles, and blogs are filling this gap.
Personally, I adore reviewing craft books. But I want to know what kinds of information you like best in book reviews. Would you mind answering a few questions? (Just leave a comment with anything that grabs you.)
———————————————————————————
1. How often do you read craft book reviews here?
2. What would you like to see more of in a craft book review?
(For example: a full list of the projects? Photos of the projects? Commentary on the quality of the instructions? Commentary on how the book fits into the current craft scene? A blog interview with the author? Comparisons with other similar books? Anything goes – what matters to you?)3. What would you like to see less of in a craft book review?
4. Why do you read craft book reviews?
———————————————————————————
Rewarding your efforts! All commenters who leave usable suggestions here will be entered in a drawing for their choice of craft book (from a little stash I have built up). I’ll choose three winners on Saturday, March 14, at noon PST.
Thank you!
I read almost all your craft book reviews.
I like the very involved coverage you give each book.
I think what I’d like to know is if you’ve tried any of the projects yourself, or purchased any of the products yourself, so you could give a direct experience along with the review.
Your reviews are mostly good about relating the books to other books or sites, but more of that would be good.
Interviews with authors? Are you kidding?! That’s the best. It gives a personal feel and a sense of accessiblity.
In particular, your thorough inclusion of images from a book which carries images is a really helpful thing, and I can always decide whether I want the book or not that way.
I read craft book reviews because I have been disappointed in some books I’ve purchased, and it saves me money to get a good, solid idea of what the flavor and scope of a book is. Your reviews are good. You are willing to note the limitations of a book as well, which can be really helpful.
Thanks!
I read almost all your craft book reviews.
I like the very involved coverage you give each book.
I think what I’d like to know is if you’ve tried any of the projects yourself, or purchased any of the products yourself, so you could give a direct experience along with the review.
Your reviews are mostly good about relating the books to other books or sites, but more of that would be good.
Interviews with authors? Are you kidding?! That’s the best. It gives a personal feel and a sense of accessiblity.
In particular, your thorough inclusion of images from a book which carries images is a really helpful thing, and I can always decide whether I want the book or not that way.
I read craft book reviews because I have been disappointed in some books I’ve purchased, and it saves me money to get a good, solid idea of what the flavor and scope of a book is. Your reviews are good. You are willing to note the limitations of a book as well, which can be really helpful.
Thanks!
1. How often do you read craft book reviews here?-I always read them when you post them, and I know I have a few bookmarked somewhere, but honestly haven’t gone back to them…someday…lol
2. What would you like to see more of in a craft book review? -My number one request would be photos of finished projects. When I go to the bookstore, I flip through the books, just looking at the projects, then decide if I’m going to look in more detail based on what I see. Unfortunately, since I do EVERYTIME I go, I have to limit myself to just the jewelry books, or else I’d be there for days on end. When I read someone else’s review, I do the same thing…scan the pics of finished products first, then decide if I want to read the whole thing.
Commentary on the instruction is always good too, as is a comparison to similar books. I, personally, don’t figure in an author interview into my decision to buy a book or not, but it’s always a nice addition.
oooh, and if you could mention the list price of the book, that’s helpful as well.
3. What would you like to see less of in a craft book review?
I really can’t think of anything.
4. Why do you read craft book reviews? -To feed my artistic ADHD, and see what I’m not doing that I should be :-)
1. How often do you read craft book reviews here?-I always read them when you post them, and I know I have a few bookmarked somewhere, but honestly haven’t gone back to them…someday…lol
2. What would you like to see more of in a craft book review? -My number one request would be photos of finished projects. When I go to the bookstore, I flip through the books, just looking at the projects, then decide if I’m going to look in more detail based on what I see. Unfortunately, since I do EVERYTIME I go, I have to limit myself to just the jewelry books, or else I’d be there for days on end. When I read someone else’s review, I do the same thing…scan the pics of finished products first, then decide if I want to read the whole thing.
Commentary on the instruction is always good too, as is a comparison to similar books. I, personally, don’t figure in an author interview into my decision to buy a book or not, but it’s always a nice addition.
oooh, and if you could mention the list price of the book, that’s helpful as well.
3. What would you like to see less of in a craft book review?
I really can’t think of anything.
4. Why do you read craft book reviews? -To feed my artistic ADHD, and see what I’m not doing that I should be :-)
I want to know if the book has inspirational photos that will keep me interested after I’ve had it for a long while. And are the projects original? Do they work? It is of great help if you have made a project and can tell us how it went, show us the results. And is it well written? Does the author have a unique voice? Something real to share? Those are things I look for in a good craft book.
I want to know if the book has inspirational photos that will keep me interested after I’ve had it for a long while. And are the projects original? Do they work? It is of great help if you have made a project and can tell us how it went, show us the results. And is it well written? Does the author have a unique voice? Something real to share? Those are things I look for in a good craft book.
hello, first, I always read carefully any craftbook review I happen to find on my way !
I share a craft blog with my mom and sister, and we always like to share our feelings about books we buy or take from the public library. Since I’m kind of the only one speaking english around, I specially like to write reviews (in french) about english or american craftbooks. I hope it will eventually encourages my blog friends to venture into english litterature (so rich as compared to old fashion crap we have here – and I don’t mean in any way “cool” old fashion …)
So far I mostly get reactions such as “I want to learn eglish or die” , which is kind of motivating, isn’t it ?
So … to get to the point : I like to read reviews because it gives me an example to follow :-)
and for you questions : do I want a full list of project ? Not necessarily, but a description of the “atmosphere” of the book (or of each chapter) with just a few typical exemples.
interview of authors? YES YES YES !!!
I would like more ? your opinion about which public the book is meant for (beginners, experienced crafters …) / price of the book / number of projects / pickup one project and try it for us ;-) so that you can say if the instructions are clear and pleasant to read / and if you occasionally thing the book is not that good … well … just let us know …
I would like les ? huuuu ???? maybe I should say I still have same interest to read thorough even is there is not much humor in it … a few more technical details would help to gauge the level of the projects.
ok, that’s it ! hope to read your next review soon !
I read the craft book on your site but not any others. I tend to trust your reviews. For instance, I’m not a button fanatic or anything but after reading your review of Button It Up, I totally want it! Plus, I like the reviews here because it keeps me up-to-date with the new books out on the market. Your blog is my one-stop shop for all things crafty.
I would love to see blog interviews with the authors if possible. Also, maybe some kind of ranking system for the majority of the projects in a book (Beginner to Advanced). I’ve purchased many craft books that were beyond my reach.
hello, first, I always read carefully any craftbook review I happen to find on my way !
I share a craft blog with my mom and sister, and we always like to share our feelings about books we buy or take from the public library. Since I’m kind of the only one speaking english around, I specially like to write reviews (in french) about english or american craftbooks. I hope it will eventually encourages my blog friends to venture into english litterature (so rich as compared to old fashion crap we have here – and I don’t mean in any way “cool” old fashion …)
So far I mostly get reactions such as “I want to learn eglish or die” , which is kind of motivating, isn’t it ?
So … to get to the point : I like to read reviews because it gives me an example to follow :-)
and for you questions : do I want a full list of project ? Not necessarily, but a description of the “atmosphere” of the book (or of each chapter) with just a few typical exemples.
interview of authors? YES YES YES !!!
I would like more ? your opinion about which public the book is meant for (beginners, experienced crafters …) / price of the book / number of projects / pickup one project and try it for us ;-) so that you can say if the instructions are clear and pleasant to read / and if you occasionally thing the book is not that good … well … just let us know …
I would like les ? huuuu ???? maybe I should say I still have same interest to read thorough even is there is not much humor in it … a few more technical details would help to gauge the level of the projects.
ok, that’s it ! hope to read your next review soon !
I read the craft book on your site but not any others. I tend to trust your reviews. For instance, I’m not a button fanatic or anything but after reading your review of Button It Up, I totally want it! Plus, I like the reviews here because it keeps me up-to-date with the new books out on the market. Your blog is my one-stop shop for all things crafty.
I would love to see blog interviews with the authors if possible. Also, maybe some kind of ranking system for the majority of the projects in a book (Beginner to Advanced). I’ve purchased many craft books that were beyond my reach.
I read lots of book reviews, because I like to do my homework before spending money on a book. I enjoy detailed reviews, especially with pictures and examples from the book. I know that when you go on Amazon you usually get the cover shot and that’s all. I like being able to see project pictures, to know if it is something I would even want to make. I also like knowing the difficulty and time span of a project, so I will know when I sit down if I will have time to finish it, or if it will take a couple of days. Interviews with the authors would be great, get their story of inspiration.
Less of nothing! I’m all for all the info I can get :) I read reviews because money is so hard to come by for me, I don’t want to waste it :)
I read lots of book reviews, because I like to do my homework before spending money on a book. I enjoy detailed reviews, especially with pictures and examples from the book. I know that when you go on Amazon you usually get the cover shot and that’s all. I like being able to see project pictures, to know if it is something I would even want to make. I also like knowing the difficulty and time span of a project, so I will know when I sit down if I will have time to finish it, or if it will take a couple of days. Interviews with the authors would be great, get their story of inspiration.
Less of nothing! I’m all for all the info I can get :) I read reviews because money is so hard to come by for me, I don’t want to waste it :)
1. How often do you read craft book reviews here?
I suscribe to the blog, so they all cross my screen and get attended to at some point. A review in a blog is far more likely to catch my attention than an ad in a magazine or other method of publicizing a book; it’s like the effect amazon reviews have on book sales in that hearing about a book in the words of someone I can identify with is the best way to get me interested.
2. What would you like to see more of in a craft book review?
If I’m going to buy a craft book it’ll be for the techniques or specific projects it teaches, so seeing the projects and techniques offered by a book really catches my attention. Sure, a review might show three or four projects then let you know that our book-at-hand has thirty more projects of awesome, but the difference between me thinking “maybe I’ll flip through that if I see it at a book store” and “I want that” is knowing if I can and want to learn what those specific projects teach. That, and I love looking at all kinds of examples of crafty goodness.
3. What would you like to see less of in a craft book review?
This, I do not know. Unless I know of the author previously I probably won’t be interested in what they have to say until after I read their book(s), unless of course their interviews involve sharing even more of ye olde crafty goodness (or until the fateful day I decide to try and put together my own craft book).
4. Why do you read craft book reviews?
Unfortunately, as a college student with no income, I can only read crafty book reviews thusfar to dream. Some day, however, I’ll read them to figure out what I want to try/buy.
1. How often do you read craft book reviews here?
I suscribe to the blog, so they all cross my screen and get attended to at some point. A review in a blog is far more likely to catch my attention than an ad in a magazine or other method of publicizing a book; it’s like the effect amazon reviews have on book sales in that hearing about a book in the words of someone I can identify with is the best way to get me interested.
2. What would you like to see more of in a craft book review?
If I’m going to buy a craft book it’ll be for the techniques or specific projects it teaches, so seeing the projects and techniques offered by a book really catches my attention. Sure, a review might show three or four projects then let you know that our book-at-hand has thirty more projects of awesome, but the difference between me thinking “maybe I’ll flip through that if I see it at a book store” and “I want that” is knowing if I can and want to learn what those specific projects teach. That, and I love looking at all kinds of examples of crafty goodness.
3. What would you like to see less of in a craft book review?
This, I do not know. Unless I know of the author previously I probably won’t be interested in what they have to say until after I read their book(s), unless of course their interviews involve sharing even more of ye olde crafty goodness (or until the fateful day I decide to try and put together my own craft book).
4. Why do you read craft book reviews?
Unfortunately, as a college student with no income, I can only read crafty book reviews thusfar to dream. Some day, however, I’ll read them to figure out what I want to try/buy.
I like reading book reviews. My city library is tiny and the only bookstore is in a mall. My access to craft books is very limited. Book reviews, particularly those with at least a few pictures inspire me, give me a sense of trends, and give me a sense of whether or not I want to try to get my hands on something.
I want to know whether the book is inspirational and lays foundations for skills, or is a simple ‘follow these steps for this exact project’. I want to know whether I’ll need a boat load of new supplies.
I like reading book reviews. My city library is tiny and the only bookstore is in a mall. My access to craft books is very limited. Book reviews, particularly those with at least a few pictures inspire me, give me a sense of trends, and give me a sense of whether or not I want to try to get my hands on something.
I want to know whether the book is inspirational and lays foundations for skills, or is a simple ‘follow these steps for this exact project’. I want to know whether I’ll need a boat load of new supplies.
I read all of your book reviews & others too. I too like to know what I’m getting before I spend my money!
One thing I’d like to know about a book is “what does this book have to offer me that others don’t?” in other words “how is this book different from the other 80 million in the stores?”
Author interviews are always enlightening & interesting!
I read all of your book reviews & others too. I too like to know what I’m getting before I spend my money!
One thing I’d like to know about a book is “what does this book have to offer me that others don’t?” in other words “how is this book different from the other 80 million in the stores?”
Author interviews are always enlightening & interesting!
I read book reviews – sure do!
Here’s what I’d like: Honesty. What is the MSRP of the book, and is it worth paying full price, scoop it off of eBay, or wait for a coupon?
Tease me. Really tease me! There’s so much good crafting out there for free on the Internet. The Artist, Publisher and Reviewer are going to have to work hard at separating me from my hard earned dollars. I want to be tempted to leave work early to go to the bookstore. I want the little fella who sits on my shoulder and talks me out of purchases to go “ok, you’ve been good this week and really deserve this book.”
I read book reviews – sure do!
Here’s what I’d like: Honesty. What is the MSRP of the book, and is it worth paying full price, scoop it off of eBay, or wait for a coupon?
Tease me. Really tease me! There’s so much good crafting out there for free on the Internet. The Artist, Publisher and Reviewer are going to have to work hard at separating me from my hard earned dollars. I want to be tempted to leave work early to go to the bookstore. I want the little fella who sits on my shoulder and talks me out of purchases to go “ok, you’ve been good this week and really deserve this book.”
I love to read book reviews from other crafters. It is difficult to find a review that isn’t a little biased but I believe your coverage of the books help us readers to make our own decision about the book before actually purchasing it. I love your inclusion of images and would agree with the previous comment about trying out a project or two of your own. I would much rather have to much information than to little, so I can’t think of anything to leave out. Just keep them coming, my book fund is drying up these days and any research I can do before purchasing a product is very helpful. :)
I love to read book reviews from other crafters. It is difficult to find a review that isn’t a little biased but I believe your coverage of the books help us readers to make our own decision about the book before actually purchasing it. I love your inclusion of images and would agree with the previous comment about trying out a project or two of your own. I would much rather have to much information than to little, so I can’t think of anything to leave out. Just keep them coming, my book fund is drying up these days and any research I can do before purchasing a product is very helpful. :)
1) I actually read every craft book review I can find (since most of the time I’m only looking for a reason to buy another one. My addiction to craft books is almost as big as my craft-addiction itself) and I particularly love your blog and podcast, so of course I read every one of your book reviews.
2) Since the amazon entry or the author’s blog often contain project lists and some photos, I would be interested in hearing your thoughts on the instructions (the quality) and for whom you think the book is most interesting (like beginners, advanced crafters).
3) I can’t really think of anything!
4) As I mentioned before, I love craft books. But in recent times, I’ve bought some books that didn’t really contain projects that matched my skills (like one book contained lots of hand-sewing, which I neither can nor want to do right now, anoher one consisted almost entirely of beginner-friendly, simple projects while I had hoped to try something new to take my sewing to the next level); since I live in Germany where there are almost no interesting craft books at all, I have to order them from the US via Amazon and have to rely on reviews of potential purchases.
Thank you for your amazing work and a big HOORAY for book release season (and for spring, which over here definately has to hurry up a bit)!!!
1) I actually read every craft book review I can find (since most of the time I’m only looking for a reason to buy another one. My addiction to craft books is almost as big as my craft-addiction itself) and I particularly love your blog and podcast, so of course I read every one of your book reviews.
2) Since the amazon entry or the author’s blog often contain project lists and some photos, I would be interested in hearing your thoughts on the instructions (the quality) and for whom you think the book is most interesting (like beginners, advanced crafters).
3) I can’t really think of anything!
4) As I mentioned before, I love craft books. But in recent times, I’ve bought some books that didn’t really contain projects that matched my skills (like one book contained lots of hand-sewing, which I neither can nor want to do right now, anoher one consisted almost entirely of beginner-friendly, simple projects while I had hoped to try something new to take my sewing to the next level); since I live in Germany where there are almost no interesting craft books at all, I have to order them from the US via Amazon and have to rely on reviews of potential purchases.
Thank you for your amazing work and a big HOORAY for book release season (and for spring, which over here definately has to hurry up a bit)!!!
I read all your craft book reviews, and especially like the photos of some of the inside pages. I like being able to see if it’s aesthetically pleasing. Face it, there are so many craft books out there, it’s the style of a publication that usually catches my eye. Project lists are great, and comparisons with other books or a discussion of what level crafter the book is aimed towards are all very helpful when I’m deciding whether or not a book is really worth buying.
I read all your craft book reviews, and especially like the photos of some of the inside pages. I like being able to see if it’s aesthetically pleasing. Face it, there are so many craft books out there, it’s the style of a publication that usually catches my eye. Project lists are great, and comparisons with other books or a discussion of what level crafter the book is aimed towards are all very helpful when I’m deciding whether or not a book is really worth buying.
I really like your book reviews — they give a good overview of the types of projects, so it’s easy to see whether a book has only 1 or 2 interesting projects or is full of them. Photos are a nice touch, and I really liked the review of the Eco Craft book that showed photos of the instructions.
I help select books for the public library I work in, as well as books for myself. It’s helpful to know what skill level and craft personality the books appeal to (beginner, granny crafts; intermediate, new mom so baby stuff only — that type of thing).
A full list of the projects isn’t necessary, but I do like to see an outline of how much of each type project is in a mixed-craft book (i.e. knitting + crocheting, but there’re only 2 crochet projects), or just a general idea of the types/usefulness of the projects so I can determine how much use I’d get out of the book.
I really like your book reviews — they give a good overview of the types of projects, so it’s easy to see whether a book has only 1 or 2 interesting projects or is full of them. Photos are a nice touch, and I really liked the review of the Eco Craft book that showed photos of the instructions.
I help select books for the public library I work in, as well as books for myself. It’s helpful to know what skill level and craft personality the books appeal to (beginner, granny crafts; intermediate, new mom so baby stuff only — that type of thing).
A full list of the projects isn’t necessary, but I do like to see an outline of how much of each type project is in a mixed-craft book (i.e. knitting + crocheting, but there’re only 2 crochet projects), or just a general idea of the types/usefulness of the projects so I can determine how much use I’d get out of the book.
1) If it’s on the blog, chances are I read it. I love book reviews anyway.
2) I really do like the nitty-gritty details, things like whether the instructions are clear and accurate, and also whether it’s more oriented to the reader doing the exact project given or more oriented to having the reader understand techniques or ideas that can be applied to projects of the reader’s devising. And like Ellyn above, I want to know what’s special about THIS book, how it compares in style, usefulness etc with other similiar books—A big part of the value of the review is that I’m pretty sure that however many craftbooks I’ve browsed through, you (the reviewer) have read more and read them more carefully. And I want to know what YOU think, since the blog gives me a pretty good sense of your taste generally. (?)
3) I don’t care all that much whether the author is a lovely and charming person. (although I’m sure she/he is.)
4) bunch of different reasons: to have some idea of what is “out there” in the crafty universe, to get general ideas for crafts I might want to try, to get specific ideas for what book might be best for a particular type of craft. Actually I really enjoy your mini-”reviews” of older craftbooks in the same way—reminds me that there is old dusty gold on the library shelves.
1) If it’s on the blog, chances are I read it. I love book reviews anyway.
2) I really do like the nitty-gritty details, things like whether the instructions are clear and accurate, and also whether it’s more oriented to the reader doing the exact project given or more oriented to having the reader understand techniques or ideas that can be applied to projects of the reader’s devising. And like Ellyn above, I want to know what’s special about THIS book, how it compares in style, usefulness etc with other similiar books—A big part of the value of the review is that I’m pretty sure that however many craftbooks I’ve browsed through, you (the reviewer) have read more and read them more carefully. And I want to know what YOU think, since the blog gives me a pretty good sense of your taste generally. (?)
3) I don’t care all that much whether the author is a lovely and charming person. (although I’m sure she/he is.)
4) bunch of different reasons: to have some idea of what is “out there” in the crafty universe, to get general ideas for crafts I might want to try, to get specific ideas for what book might be best for a particular type of craft. Actually I really enjoy your mini-”reviews” of older craftbooks in the same way—reminds me that there is old dusty gold on the library shelves.
1. How often do you read craft book reviews here?
When ever you care to post one my dear! I read it thoroughly, look at all images and follow the link to add it to my wish list if it looks like a book I’d consider buying.
2. What would you like to see more of in a craft book review?
A craft book review doesn’t need a list of chapters or all projects if you ask me, but images are always fun to get a feel for the book (coz I can’t go to borders and sit on the floor and read it before buying)… I like when there are links to the authors blog or the books homepage if it has one.
As I myself have written hundreds of book reviews over the years I think it’s important that you as the reviewer give a correct view or YOUR opinions on the book. Is this a book you want to keep and do projects from? I know what kind of projects get you going, and if you like the book that gives me an idea if I will like it too… That means reading it from first page to last and telling me what works out, what doesn’t and who, if not you, you would recommend get this book.
Interviews are also fun but not a part of the review for sure. The author has no say now, it’s your turn to tell. I LOVE when you are honest and not afraid to say no thank you too.
3. What would you like to see less of in a craft book review?
Oh, this is another lovely book that you all should go buy (hey editor are you reading my review – send me more book).
4. Why do you read craft book reviews?
Many reasons; to be informed, to find inspiration, go get a feeling for if it’s a book that I think I need. Not many books I feel I actually NEED, so reading a review can sometimes help me NOT to spend… hehe. I want to know if the photos are to dark, the layout difficult or the projects to boring. I hate when I spend money on bad books and get disappointed. I mostly crave art books these days, and I’m so happy that it doesn’t happen that I’m disappointed very often!
oh, and I really think it’s fun if you actually have the time to DO one or two projects from the book. that, beyond words, would tell me you got inspired by it. and that my friend, inspires me to get me crafting…
oh, again, I didn’t mean for this to be THIS long but another thing came to mind… I really really like reviews of 2 or more similar books on the market. I don’t think you need to tell which one is the winner but to kill to birds with one stone, for a reviewer, this is kind of nice to do… example: I’ve read three books on crochet, the first one is good for this, the other one is better if you’re into that… and so on.
1. How often do you read craft book reviews here?
When ever you care to post one my dear! I read it thoroughly, look at all images and follow the link to add it to my wish list if it looks like a book I’d consider buying.
2. What would you like to see more of in a craft book review?
A craft book review doesn’t need a list of chapters or all projects if you ask me, but images are always fun to get a feel for the book (coz I can’t go to borders and sit on the floor and read it before buying)… I like when there are links to the authors blog or the books homepage if it has one.
As I myself have written hundreds of book reviews over the years I think it’s important that you as the reviewer give a correct view or YOUR opinions on the book. Is this a book you want to keep and do projects from? I know what kind of projects get you going, and if you like the book that gives me an idea if I will like it too… That means reading it from first page to last and telling me what works out, what doesn’t and who, if not you, you would recommend get this book.
Interviews are also fun but not a part of the review for sure. The author has no say now, it’s your turn to tell. I LOVE when you are honest and not afraid to say no thank you too.
3. What would you like to see less of in a craft book review?
Oh, this is another lovely book that you all should go buy (hey editor are you reading my review – send me more book).
4. Why do you read craft book reviews?
Many reasons; to be informed, to find inspiration, go get a feeling for if it’s a book that I think I need. Not many books I feel I actually NEED, so reading a review can sometimes help me NOT to spend… hehe. I want to know if the photos are to dark, the layout difficult or the projects to boring. I hate when I spend money on bad books and get disappointed. I mostly crave art books these days, and I’m so happy that it doesn’t happen that I’m disappointed very often!
oh, and I really think it’s fun if you actually have the time to DO one or two projects from the book. that, beyond words, would tell me you got inspired by it. and that my friend, inspires me to get me crafting…
oh, again, I didn’t mean for this to be THIS long but another thing came to mind… I really really like reviews of 2 or more similar books on the market. I don’t think you need to tell which one is the winner but to kill to birds with one stone, for a reviewer, this is kind of nice to do… example: I’ve read three books on crochet, the first one is good for this, the other one is better if you’re into that… and so on.
1. I LOVE your book reviews! I just found your blog and went back and read a ton of reviews.
2. I love that you show pics of some of the projects so I have an idea of what is in the book. Sometimes there are images on Amazon, but you usually only get the first few pages and most books don’t start showing projects there. I would like to see a full list of all the projects because not all books on Amazon let you “see inside.” I also enjoy when you discuss if the instructions seem clearly written, but I would also like an idea of the difficulty level. I know that sometimes you can’t always tell, but I like to know if the projects are for beginners or more advanced crafters. I’m a beginner crafter in some areas, so I don’t want to purchase a book that is way above my level.
3. Umm, they’re all really good.
4. I read craft reviews because I have a huge addiction to craft books but no money for them! Reading a review gives me a good idea if the book is worth spending my hard-earned money on.
1. I LOVE your book reviews! I just found your blog and went back and read a ton of reviews.
2. I love that you show pics of some of the projects so I have an idea of what is in the book. Sometimes there are images on Amazon, but you usually only get the first few pages and most books don’t start showing projects there. I would like to see a full list of all the projects because not all books on Amazon let you “see inside.” I also enjoy when you discuss if the instructions seem clearly written, but I would also like an idea of the difficulty level. I know that sometimes you can’t always tell, but I like to know if the projects are for beginners or more advanced crafters. I’m a beginner crafter in some areas, so I don’t want to purchase a book that is way above my level.
3. Umm, they’re all really good.
4. I read craft reviews because I have a huge addiction to craft books but no money for them! Reading a review gives me a good idea if the book is worth spending my hard-earned money on.
1. I do read craft book reviews, however less so than I used to (see item 3)
2. I agree with commenter Dan that more project pictures would be nice, but I know that’s not always possible.
3. The reason I read less blog reviews than I used to is – maybe I’m only going on kind people sites, but I rarely see any negatives or drawbacks mentioned. I take the time to read the reader reviews on Amazon since they tend to be more blunt, but it seems as if most bloggers practice the, “if you can’t say anything nice don’t say anything at all”, philosophy. I’ve cut down considerably on ordering craft books on-line because I got caught up in the excitement about a number of books and ended up not using them at all.
4. I really love to see what is burbling out of the craft community’s creative consciousness.
Karen
1. I do read craft book reviews, however less so than I used to (see item 3)
2. I agree with commenter Dan that more project pictures would be nice, but I know that’s not always possible.
3. The reason I read less blog reviews than I used to is – maybe I’m only going on kind people sites, but I rarely see any negatives or drawbacks mentioned. I take the time to read the reader reviews on Amazon since they tend to be more blunt, but it seems as if most bloggers practice the, “if you can’t say anything nice don’t say anything at all”, philosophy. I’ve cut down considerably on ordering craft books on-line because I got caught up in the excitement about a number of books and ended up not using them at all.
4. I really love to see what is burbling out of the craft community’s creative consciousness.
Karen
1. How often do you read craft book reviews here?
I read them whenever they are posted, I love to see new craft books
2. What would you like to see more of in a craft book review?
I would really like to see a full list of the projects, and pictures pictures pictures! I (probably like most crafters) am a visual person and the finished amazing projects are totally what drive me to get the book.
I also really appreciate your experience with any of the projects, directions, or general feeling of the book. I don’t expect that every book will be perfect, and if it’s not it won’t keep me from buying it if it looks like something I am interested in. I also know that not every book will be for me and your first hand experience helps me evaluate it.
3. What would you like to see less of in a craft book review?
I can’t really think of anything- Lengthy author interviews aren’t as important to me as pictures. I think I’d rather see an author interview after the book has been out for a while.
4. Why do you read craft book reviews?
I love to get craft books and the reviews let me know about the newest things being published. Also I tend to read blog reviews more than magazine reviews since I really value the first hand experience.
1. How often do you read craft book reviews here?
I read them whenever they are posted, I love to see new craft books
2. What would you like to see more of in a craft book review?
I would really like to see a full list of the projects, and pictures pictures pictures! I (probably like most crafters) am a visual person and the finished amazing projects are totally what drive me to get the book.
I also really appreciate your experience with any of the projects, directions, or general feeling of the book. I don’t expect that every book will be perfect, and if it’s not it won’t keep me from buying it if it looks like something I am interested in. I also know that not every book will be for me and your first hand experience helps me evaluate it.
3. What would you like to see less of in a craft book review?
I can’t really think of anything- Lengthy author interviews aren’t as important to me as pictures. I think I’d rather see an author interview after the book has been out for a while.
4. Why do you read craft book reviews?
I love to get craft books and the reviews let me know about the newest things being published. Also I tend to read blog reviews more than magazine reviews since I really value the first hand experience.
1. I always at least look at the pictures of book reviews, and if the subject interests me (or if the pictures make me interested) then I read the whole thing.
2. I am a very visual thinker and pictures are what matter most to me both in craft books themselves (generally speaking) and in the reviews when I’m deciding whether to buy a book, so project photos (or photos of page layouts) are always a plus. I’m also interested in hearing how the book fits in with/differs from other similar books, and with the online craft community – like, what can I get from this book that I can’t get just from reading blogs or searching for information about the subject. I’m a big fan of books that get me excited to create, or excited about a particular craft that I might not have thought would interest me – so I’d want reviews to tell me about this kind of enthusiasm. Like, maybe there’s not the best ever how-to pictures, or even the most original projects, but if it’s written about in a way that makes me want to play, then I want the book!
3. hmm, less of… I guess I’m most interested in why the book stands out amongst other books like it, so if a review talks about the book having a hip style/aesthetic or stuff like that, to me that kind of means it has the same look as a lot of other books and blogs, so I don’t really care. I don’t know if that makes sense, because having a cool look isn’t a bad thing, it just isn’t something that I want reviews to focus on… I can’t really think of anything else, because usually the more information the better.
4. I love love love craft books and I always want to buy every one I see, so I read reviews to try to narrow it down and figure out which ones are reeally worth it to me and which ones would probably sit on my shelf and not get used.
1. I always at least look at the pictures of book reviews, and if the subject interests me (or if the pictures make me interested) then I read the whole thing.
2. I am a very visual thinker and pictures are what matter most to me both in craft books themselves (generally speaking) and in the reviews when I’m deciding whether to buy a book, so project photos (or photos of page layouts) are always a plus. I’m also interested in hearing how the book fits in with/differs from other similar books, and with the online craft community – like, what can I get from this book that I can’t get just from reading blogs or searching for information about the subject. I’m a big fan of books that get me excited to create, or excited about a particular craft that I might not have thought would interest me – so I’d want reviews to tell me about this kind of enthusiasm. Like, maybe there’s not the best ever how-to pictures, or even the most original projects, but if it’s written about in a way that makes me want to play, then I want the book!
3. hmm, less of… I guess I’m most interested in why the book stands out amongst other books like it, so if a review talks about the book having a hip style/aesthetic or stuff like that, to me that kind of means it has the same look as a lot of other books and blogs, so I don’t really care. I don’t know if that makes sense, because having a cool look isn’t a bad thing, it just isn’t something that I want reviews to focus on… I can’t really think of anything else, because usually the more information the better.
4. I love love love craft books and I always want to buy every one I see, so I read reviews to try to narrow it down and figure out which ones are reeally worth it to me and which ones would probably sit on my shelf and not get used.
I read your book reviews to see what you say about them, really. I’m super picky about books, so I really want to see them myself anyway.
When I was posting about the vintage Japanese craft book someone left a comment and said they thought they were on CraftyPod when they first clicked through to my site. Ha! :)
I read your book reviews to see what you say about them, really. I’m super picky about books, so I really want to see them myself anyway.
When I was posting about the vintage Japanese craft book someone left a comment and said they thought they were on CraftyPod when they first clicked through to my site. Ha! :)
1. How often do you read craft book reviews here?
The craft reviews were what originally brought me to this blog, and since then I read them every time you post one.
2. What would you like to see more of in a craft book review?
I like knowing how detailed the instructions in the book are, and if the instructions are clear and if needed, pictures are printed to help. I want to know about any bad points in the book, ex. lack of clear instructions, lack of images, or just plain bad writing. If there are other books that are better it is nice to know, and its nice to know also what other books will go well with the book you are reviewing.
3. What would you like to see less of in a craft book review?
I don’t know actually. Your reviews have been helpful. um, I don’t really care about the authors personal life if I am going to be reading their book. I’m more interested in hearing about their qualifications then where they live, or who they live with. sounds kinda bitchy, but after awhile I would just stop paying attention to the review if it focused on the author’s life rather then their craft. I know they are tied together but when its paragraphs and paragraphs about the author’s life and hardly anything about the crafts involved it gets boring very fast.
4. Why do you read craft book reviews?
To get an idea if its worth spending the money on the book. Books are too much money to buy one and then find its not really what you were looking for.
1. How often do you read craft book reviews here?
The craft reviews were what originally brought me to this blog, and since then I read them every time you post one.
2. What would you like to see more of in a craft book review?
I like knowing how detailed the instructions in the book are, and if the instructions are clear and if needed, pictures are printed to help. I want to know about any bad points in the book, ex. lack of clear instructions, lack of images, or just plain bad writing. If there are other books that are better it is nice to know, and its nice to know also what other books will go well with the book you are reviewing.
3. What would you like to see less of in a craft book review?
I don’t know actually. Your reviews have been helpful. um, I don’t really care about the authors personal life if I am going to be reading their book. I’m more interested in hearing about their qualifications then where they live, or who they live with. sounds kinda bitchy, but after awhile I would just stop paying attention to the review if it focused on the author’s life rather then their craft. I know they are tied together but when its paragraphs and paragraphs about the author’s life and hardly anything about the crafts involved it gets boring very fast.
4. Why do you read craft book reviews?
To get an idea if its worth spending the money on the book. Books are too much money to buy one and then find its not really what you were looking for.
Hi Diane! =c)
I definitely love it when you review craft books! Even if they are not in a craft or art technique I am interested in doing myself, it is always fun to see what you have to say about them. You are into so many different things!
I don’t have time to find out what new books are out there and the bookstores around here really don’t shift their inventory very much, so I totally appreciate when bloggers do book reviews. iHanna just posted some new books she’s been looking at on her website (www.ihanna.nu/blog) and I am going to get at least two of them that I didn’t know about until she posted them.
I even a bought a book that you reviewed, “Mixed Mania” and I had never bought a book that I can’t physically flip through before I buy it. I bought it because I loved the sample pages you showed and your description of some of the more unique projects. (and ended up loving this book so much I reviewed it on Amazon.com!!) So there’s an answer to one of your questions…I love to see pictures of the inside of the book. I am more into altered/mixed media art than crafty stuff (though I adore your site, please don’t be offended!) and I hate scrapbooky stuff, so I guess I am more particular than I thought. –It’s just best if I can see how the book is set up and what projects there are before I make a decision if it’s my style.
Another thing I like in book reviews is information on the unique-ness of the projects. (I guess this fits into the “fitting into the modern craft scene” part.) I have a lot of craft books and some of them are practically carbon copies of each other. I loved Mixed Mania because it showed some simple (and a few complex) techniques, but in ways other books hadn’t put them together. One can only be “introduced” to ATC’s so many times.
I’m starting to get into knitting right now too and so reviews of new knitting (and even crocheting!) would be appreciated. I think you understand that sometimes the books are just pattern after pattern of boring or complicated sweaters and scarves and some of the more modern ones have stuffies or neat little accessories to make that are out of the box regarding the old ones.
Anyway, hope this helps! I totally think that bloggers should get some sort of commission for writing book reviews. When I bought Mixed Media I wish that some of the money would have went to you because I wouldn’t have known about this fabulous little book if it weren’t for you!!
(Oh and by the way.. I have checked out the 200 Crochet Squares book from the library and it is AWESOME!!)
Hi Diane! =c)
I definitely love it when you review craft books! Even if they are not in a craft or art technique I am interested in doing myself, it is always fun to see what you have to say about them. You are into so many different things!
I don’t have time to find out what new books are out there and the bookstores around here really don’t shift their inventory very much, so I totally appreciate when bloggers do book reviews. iHanna just posted some new books she’s been looking at on her website (www.ihanna.nu/blog) and I am going to get at least two of them that I didn’t know about until she posted them.
I even a bought a book that you reviewed, “Mixed Mania” and I had never bought a book that I can’t physically flip through before I buy it. I bought it because I loved the sample pages you showed and your description of some of the more unique projects. (and ended up loving this book so much I reviewed it on Amazon.com!!) So there’s an answer to one of your questions…I love to see pictures of the inside of the book. I am more into altered/mixed media art than crafty stuff (though I adore your site, please don’t be offended!) and I hate scrapbooky stuff, so I guess I am more particular than I thought. –It’s just best if I can see how the book is set up and what projects there are before I make a decision if it’s my style.
Another thing I like in book reviews is information on the unique-ness of the projects. (I guess this fits into the “fitting into the modern craft scene” part.) I have a lot of craft books and some of them are practically carbon copies of each other. I loved Mixed Mania because it showed some simple (and a few complex) techniques, but in ways other books hadn’t put them together. One can only be “introduced” to ATC’s so many times.
I’m starting to get into knitting right now too and so reviews of new knitting (and even crocheting!) would be appreciated. I think you understand that sometimes the books are just pattern after pattern of boring or complicated sweaters and scarves and some of the more modern ones have stuffies or neat little accessories to make that are out of the box regarding the old ones.
Anyway, hope this helps! I totally think that bloggers should get some sort of commission for writing book reviews. When I bought Mixed Media I wish that some of the money would have went to you because I wouldn’t have known about this fabulous little book if it weren’t for you!!
(Oh and by the way.. I have checked out the 200 Crochet Squares book from the library and it is AWESOME!!)
I read your book reviews but I don’t have a budget to buy books. I do take lots out of the library and do like to read about new books.
I like the photos that you show. I’m not into interviews with authors. I do like a rating of the instruction quality and comparisons with other books. I do like critical reviews that point out faults of books as well as positives.
I read reviews because I like to see what’s out there as new books and someday I might be able to buy books…
I read your book reviews but I don’t have a budget to buy books. I do take lots out of the library and do like to read about new books.
I like the photos that you show. I’m not into interviews with authors. I do like a rating of the instruction quality and comparisons with other books. I do like critical reviews that point out faults of books as well as positives.
I read reviews because I like to see what’s out there as new books and someday I might be able to buy books…
1. I read all your reviews, in fact, I read all your posts.
2. I would like to see more balance. All your comments are positive which sometimes make me wonder if you have an agreement with the author to promote the book. For this very reason, I don’t use your reviews in deciding whether I should purchase said book. (Sorry for the bluntness, Diane, but I thought you would appreciate my honest opinions.)
1. I read all your reviews, in fact, I read all your posts.
2. I would like to see more balance. All your comments are positive which sometimes make me wonder if you have an agreement with the author to promote the book. For this very reason, I don’t use your reviews in deciding whether I should purchase said book. (Sorry for the bluntness, Diane, but I thought you would appreciate my honest opinions.)